We Give Hope

Hope by the Sea has helped, healed and given hope to thousands through our accredited addiction programs and services.
The miracle of recovery can be yours too.

CHOOSE A PROGRAM

Monday, June 25, 2012

Should Sobriety Be Prerequisite To Receive A Liver Transplant?

The New England Journal of Medicine
The New England Journal of Medicine (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Should sobriety be a prerequisite for a person to receive a liver transplant? Unless you or a loved one is in need of a life-saving liver transplant this probably is not a question that you have considered. The reason we are talking about this question today is that once again a young person's inability to stay sober has been the deciding factor for rejecting him to receive a liver transplant.

The latest article also comes from the United Kingdom. The headline reads "Man dies from binge-drinking at age of just 22, three years after he's rejected for transplant."  His name was Gareth Anderson; his liver failure began when he was 19. His devastated father explains how out of control Gareth's life has been for the last three years: kidney failure, jail, intensive care, binge-drinking, arrested for assault. Two weeks ago, Gareth died in hospital surrounded by his family. According to the article: "Gareth Anderson is thought to be one of the youngest victims of chronic alcohol abuse in the U.K."

In November 2011 the Huffington Post reported on a study that was published in the New England Journal of Medicine. The study was conducted in France and found:

"...the vast majority of the patients who got a liver without the wait stopped drinking after their surgery and were sober years later. The study involved patients who were suffering from alcohol-related hepatitis so severe that they were unlikely to survive a six-month delay."

This is a heated debate. Those involved include the very sick in need of a liver transplant (both alcoholics and non-alcoholics), the medical community, the medical research community, affected families, insurance companies...the list goes on. As Dr. Robert S. Brown Jr., transplant director of New York -Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center while agreeing it may be time to reconsider the six-month rule he went on to tell the Huffington Post:

 "The challenge of this paper [French study] is to come up with better ways, both to treat alcoholism as a disease and to predict who will succeed with transplantation."

Not all liver transplant applicants are alcoholics, many suffer from liver disease stemming from obesity, drug use, hepatitis C resulting from reasons other than drug use. But it would appear that only alcoholics must meet a "special" life style change prerequisite in order to qualify for a transplant. 

Your comments are welcome.
Enhanced by Zemanta

1 comment:

  1. It's a very sad thing when someone is rejected something that would save their life simply because they have made some poor choices I think that they should have to be trying to be sober to get the transplant so they don't ruin it right after they get it however.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for your comment!

CignaAetnaBlueCross BlueShieldUnited HealthcareMore Options/Verify Benefits

START THE ADMISSION PROCESS

866.930.4673